270gr Cast HP vs buck

Hunter26

Beginner
Jul 10, 2024
37
98
I shot a small buck a few years back with a Ruger Super Blackhawk Hunter in .44 Mag that was massaged by SSK. I cast bullets from Lyman mold 429640 with wheel weights with a little tin added. With lube and gas check they weigh 270 grs. They shot quite well, putting a cylinder full under three inches at 50 yards. The buck was a smallish but wide 6 pt around 35 yards. The buck was almost facing me at the shot. He dropped at the shot and the bullet took an interesting path. It went the full length of the deer, into his ham, then angled down and was found days later while butchering the hind quarter in the buck's knee joint. The buck was acting odd when I saw him and during the skinning process I found out why. He had multiple broken ribs, a broken leg that was almost healed and several small shotgun pellets in his side. I didn't weigh him, but I believe he was around 130 lbs. In the picture, he's the buck on the left. The buck on the right was shot the same morning with the same load about 90 mins apart. The bullet exited the bigger bodied buck and he dropped like a rock. That was the first time I ever doubled on bucks.

The bullet was loaded over 2400 powder and velocity was a tick over 1300 fps in the 7.5 inch barrel. Recovered bullet weighed 183 grains and shed the hollow point. I shot a few more deer with this load and they always exited. If they ran, which was never far, there was always a blood trail that even Ray Charles could have followed! Too bad it's a single cavity mold and they're slow as crap to make!
 

Attachments

  • 20240724_174104.jpg
    20240724_174104.jpg
    244.8 KB · Views: 14
  • 20240724_174053.jpg
    20240724_174053.jpg
    312.8 KB · Views: 12
  • 20240724_174045.jpg
    20240724_174045.jpg
    312 KB · Views: 12
  • 20240724_174042.jpg
    20240724_174042.jpg
    292.6 KB · Views: 15
  • 2013-11-30_09-42-49_898.jpg
    2013-11-30_09-42-49_898.jpg
    497.2 KB · Views: 14
Nice, good luck! What specific bullet are you going with? I shot several deer, including a nice old buck with the Lyman 429421 Keith SWC out of the same gun. They were very accurate, but deer always ran and blood trails were on the thin side. They never went more than 50ish yards, but where I hunt, the lack of decent blood can be a big problem because it's so thick in some areas. I prefer a softer cast bullet and/or a hollow point of some kind for hunting.
 
Nice, good luck! What specific bullet are you going with? I shot several deer, including a nice old buck with the Lyman 429421 Keith SWC out of the same gun. They were very accurate, but deer always ran and blood trails were on the thin side. They never went more than 50ish yards, but where I hunt, the lack of decent blood can be a big problem because it's so thick in some areas. I prefer a softer cast bullet and/or a hollow point of some kind for hunting.
Rim Rock Bullets 240 gr HP. It's a softer hard cast bullet based off the Keith style with a lube groove and a gas check.


In the past, I've used Nosler 250 gr PT and 240 gr JHP bullets out of my 629 Classic 6 3/8" barrel.
Need to get my 629 3" bloodied.

JD338
 
That looks a lot like the Ray Thompson SWC, which is a great bullet. That should definitely do the trick, especially if it's cast soft enough to expand, with a BHN of 12 you should be good. I wish Nosler still made the Partition for big bore pistols. Luckily Swift makes the A-Frames in a bunch of pistol calibers, but they're pricey. I have some of the 180gr .40 cal A-Frames I want to try getting a deer with in my 10mm.
 
Back
Top